Best Toast Clothes 2026: The 6 We'd Buy

The Orla is the Toast idea in one garment: a plain, easy-fitting jumper made interesting by the yarn. The wool is spun in Donegal and carries the coloured flecks, or nepp, that Donegal yarn is known for. The shape is simple, with raglan sleeves, a ribbed neck and hem with rolled edges, and a mid-hip length. It is 100% wool, hand wash only, and made in Romania. The navy averaged 4.8 from 121 reviews when we read it.

The criticisms are worth knowing. Several reviewers found the wool coarse or scratchy, one enough to stop wearing it, and wear a T-shirt underneath. Others found the body short or the A-line shape stiff at the back. One expected it to be knitted in Ireland; only the yarn is. The page warns that soft yarns pill.

The Annie is the jean regular Toast customers own in several colours, and the indigo pair carried 511 reviews averaging 4.7 when we read it. It sits on the waist with a flat front, side corozo buttons instead of a fly, topstitched carpenter pockets and a buttoned back pocket, then falls straight to the ankle. It is 98% organic cotton with 2% elastane, made in Türkiye and machine washable. The page warns of colour rub when new.

The low ratings are about fit and finish. Several buyers say sizing has changed, with a narrow, high waist or tight thighs compared with an older pair, and one found the button placket unreinforced. Taller buyers have long complained about the cropped length; Toast now sells the Annie Denim Full Length Jeans for them.

This is a lot of money for a cotton coat, and the reason is the cloth. The waxed organic cotton comes from Halley Stevensons, a Dundee mill, and the coat is cut to a gentle A-line with raglan sleeves, large patch pockets, a deep back vent and a lining, finishing at mid-calf. It is made in Romania and needs a specialist dry cleaner. The page says uneven colour and gradual fading are part of waxed cotton, not a defect.

Reviews average 4.6 from 39, and they agree on one problem: it is narrow across the shoulders. Several buyers sized up, and one who normally wears a medium found the large too tight there. Others mention creasing and very little wax, and most of the four-star reviews dock a star for the price.

Toast’s menswear is smaller than its womenswear and easy to overlook, but the Rory is worth finding. The denim is dyed and woven on traditional shuttle looms in Ibara, Okayama, and the jeans are cut with straight legs, an easy fit below the waist, a reinforced back and mismatched patch pockets, one on the side of the leg. They are 100% cotton, made in China, and go in the machine at 30 degrees. Reviews averaged 4.9 from 46.

The only below-five-star review with detail is specific. Its writer loves them but found more loose threads than usual around the belt loops and buttons, and said they bag at the knee and seat after a long sit, until the next wash. The page also warns that indigo will rub onto pale fabrics.

Toast began with nightwear, and these are a good reminder why. The organic cotton is double-faced, brushed chambray outside and striped within, so turned-up cuffs show the stripe. The top has a collar, corozo buttons and a patch pocket; the trousers have an elasticated drawstring waist with herringbone ties and side pockets. They are 100% cotton, made in India and machine washable at 30 degrees, and unlike some rivals’ pyjamas they come as a set.

Reviews average 4.7 from 34, and one swimming group buys them for each other as gifts. The complaints: one buyer found the trousers enormous next to the top, a repeat buyer found the same size two inches bigger this time, and the cloth is thick enough to be too warm in summer.

If the Orla sounds too scratchy, this is the softer choice. It is a regular-fit crew neck with an integrally knitted yoke and offset ribbing at the cuffs and hem, in 70% wool and 30% cashmere; the description calls the cashmere recycled. It is mid-hip length, hand wash only and made in China. The dark navy averaged 4.7 from 22 reviews, and one buyer said a similar Toast jumper had lasted over ten years with a couple of repairs.

The weak points are proportion and pilling. The page lists the sleeve as longer length, and two reviewers returned it because the sleeves or body were too long; another found the neckline higher than expected. A happy repeat buyer still reported considerable pilling, so budget for a pilling comb.